
Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch slice after errands on Purchase Street, a bar-style thin crust after a Sound Shore night out, or authentic artisan pies for a Friday family dinner, the pizza landscape in Rye and surrounding towns offers exceptional variety.
MyRye.com’s Best of guides are determined using our Sound Shore Score methodology. We evaluate combined review scores, volume, proximity, and local reputation relative to Rye City Hall to rank the top 10 pizza spots across Rye, Port Chester, Harrison, Mamaroneck, Rye Brook, and Greenwich.
Tell us who you think is the best by leaving a comment below.

1. Sal’s Pizza — Mamaroneck
- Sound Shore Score: 4.6★ on 1,100+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: A legendary Westchester institution that continues to benchmark classic New York-style street slices with zero pretension. Its high-volume consistency and distinctively seasoned dough make it well worth the quick trip down Boston Post Road.
- Signature Recommendation: Sicilian Slice or Salad Slice
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 2.8 miles (~7 min drive)
- Location: 316 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543 | (914) 381-2022
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing

2. Colony Grill — Port Chester
- Sound Shore Score: 4.5★ on 950+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Famous for its razor-thin tavern-style crust, Colony Grill delivers a unique pizza experience that draws crowds across the Sound Shore. The lively atmosphere and iconic hot oil drizzle keep locals coming back week after week.
- Signature Recommendation: Thin-Crust Pie with Hot Oil & Stingers
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 2.6 miles (~6 min drive)
- Location: 35 Abendroth Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573 | (914) 934-2428
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing

3. Grigg Street Pizza — Greenwich, CT
- Sound Shore Score: 4.7★ on 380+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Craft sourdough crusts and top-tier ingredients elevate this nearby Greenwich spot into elite territory for artisan pizza fans. Everything is made in-house with meticulous technique, creating slices that balance airy structure with rich flavor.
- Signature Recommendation: Sourdough Pepperoni Pie with Honey Drizzle
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 5.1 miles (~12 min drive)
- Location: 1 Grigg St, Greenwich, CT 06830 | (203) 717-1190
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing

4. Sunrise Pizzeria — Downtown Rye
- Sound Shore Score: 4.4★ on 280+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Holding down the highest ranking within Rye proper, Sunrise is the quintessential neighborhood joint that generations of local families depend on. Reliable service, generous toppings, and a perfectly crisp traditional crust secure its status as a downtown mainstay.
- Signature Recommendation: Chicken Parmigiana Slice
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 0.3 miles (~1 min drive / 5 min walk)
- Location: 7 Purdy Ave, Rye, NY 10580 | (914) 967-8696
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing

5. Al Dente Pizzeria — Downtown Rye
- Sound Shore Score: 4.5★ on 210+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Tucked just off Purchase Street, Al Dente balances classic pizza counter convenience with sit-down Italian comfort food. Their brick-oven style pies stand out for their fresh basil sauce and well-balanced cheese ratio.
- Signature Recommendation: Margherita Brick-Oven Pie
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 0.2 miles (~1 min drive / 4 min walk)
- Location: 7 Elm Pl, Rye, NY 10580 | (914) 921-5300
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing
6. Pizza 2000 — Harrison
- Sound Shore Score: 4.3★ on 310+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: A favorite stop for Harrison and Rye commuters alike, Pizza 2000 is renowned for its crispy crusts and expansive specialty slice display. Their Grandma pie is widely regarded as one of the finest square slices along the Sound Shore.
- Signature Recommendation: Grandma Slice
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 1.9 miles (~5 min drive)
- Location: 337 Halstead Ave, Harrison, NY 10528 | (914) 835-8000
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing
7. Frankie & Louie’s — Port Chester
- Sound Shore Score: 4.6★ on 180+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Combining old-school neighborhood charm with high-quality ingredients, Frankie & Louie’s serves comforting pizza with a golden, sturdy crust. It’s a local go-to when you want a classic pie cooked to perfection every single time.
- Signature Recommendation: Sausage & Roasted Red Pepper Pie
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 2.9 miles (~7 min drive)
- Location: 414 Willett Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573 | (914) 939-0202
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing
8. Piazza Pizza — Milton Point / Rye
- Sound Shore Score: 4.5★ on 140+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Serving the Milton Point neighborhood, Piazza Pizza is the ultimate community hub for post-game team dinners and beach-bound lunch runs. Their personal and full-sized pies offer robust flavor with a signature crispy bottom.
- Signature Recommendation: Buffalo Chicken Pie
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 1.1 miles (~3 min drive)
- Location: 520 Milton Rd, Rye, NY 10580 | (914) 921-4444
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing

9. Fortina — Rye Brook
- Sound Shore Score: 4.2★ on 420+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: Located in the Rye Ridge Shopping Center, Fortina brings energy and wood-fired Neapolitan flair to modern pizza dining. Its char-blistered crusts and inventive topping combinations offer a stylish twist on traditional Italian pies.
- Signature Recommendation: The Luigi Vampa (Habenero, Spicy Sopressata, Sweet Onion, Mozzarella)
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 2.4 miles (~6 min drive)
- Location: 136 S Ridge St, Rye Brook, NY 10573 | (914) 937-0900
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing
10. T&J Restaurant & Pizzeria — Port Chester
- Sound Shore Score: 4.5★ on 310+ Reviews
- Why It Made the List: A family-run fixture near the Port Chester waterfront, T&J delivers authentic Italian comfort food alongside robust, classic takeaway pies. The generous cheese-to-sauce ratio makes it a favorite for feeding hungry gatherings.
- Signature Recommendation: Special Combo Pie (Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers)
- Proximity to Rye City Hall: 2.3 miles (~6 min drive)
- Location: 10 Pearl St, Port Chester, NY 10573 | (914) 939-4134
- Directions: Google Maps Directions from Rye City Hall
- Listing Source: Google Maps / Yelp Listing
MyRye.com’s Sound Shore Score Methodology
These ratings were collected October 2026. Minimum threshold of 20–25 reviews applied. We use AI to rank using a weighted index combining average star rating, total review volume, and local geographical relevance to Rye City Hall (1051 Boston Post Rd, Rye, NY).

