resident speaking at public meeting
(PHOTO: Danielle Tagger, head of the local Rye Democrats and a former Rye City Council member, called for Jewish representation at the city’s tree lighting and tree display at the Rye City Council on Wednesday evening, November 12, 2026.) Credit: MyRye.com

At Rye City Council on Wednesday evening, November 12, 2026, there was a call for Jewish representation at Rye’s second annual tree lighting and at its longtime Christmas tree display adjacent to Citibank on the Boston Post Road. The call was made by Danielle Tagger, head of the local Rye Democrats and a former Rye City Council member, having served a 4-year term from 2015 to 2019.

“Tomorrow, families will gather for the holiday stroll, which this year includes a tree lighting ceremony,” said Tagger. “The city’s website, the Rye Chamber of Commerce, and many of our local businesses have promoted this event. In addition, every year the tree outside the Citibank is also lit and brightens city property.

These are wonderful traditions, and I hope they continue for many years. But for about 10 years, I’ve asked whether a menorah could be lit as well, and I’ve been told respectfully that the city doesn’t hold a tree lighting, and I understood that. But tomorrow’s holiday stroll does include a tree lighting ceremony on city property, promoted to the whole community, and the Citibank tree shows that the city already welcomes private sponsors to share holiday displays on public property. Either way, there is room for a menorah.”

Tagger went on to cite several legal cases, including a Supreme Court case, which supported her advocacy for the display of a menorah. Tagger was one of the five founders of the local pRYEde group that, in 2021, won a battle to display the Pride flag each year on city property, at Rye City Hall and Rye Recreation. She is a former chair of the Rye City Human Rights Commission as served when a Pride flag was burned in the Bradford Park neighborhood of Rye.

Group in front of Christmas tree.
(PHOTO: The first annual Christmas tree lighting in downtown Rye on Purchase Street, November 20, 2025.) Credit: MyRye.com
The Pride flag raising at Rye City Hall on June 1st, 2021 DSC_0912
(PHOTO: The Pride flag raising at Rye City Hall on June 1st, 2021.) Credit: MyRye.com, Pei Pei Martin.

“I want Jewish families who have lived here for decades and new families just moving in to feel that this is their city too,” continued Tagger. “A menorah next to a tree doesn’t take anything away from anyone. It simply says that in Rye, there’s room for everyone’s light.”

“We will consider your thoughts,” said Rye Mayor Josh Nathan. “As you know, we all know there’s a lot to this. Shouldn’t be so complicated, but it is a little complicated. That doesn’t mean it can’t be addressed. So we will endeavor to look at this quickly.”

Later in the public meeting, Nathan asked Rye City Council Kristen Wilson for guidance after the meeting related to a menorah display.

Hanukkah begins at sundown on Friday, December 4, 2026, and ends at nightfall on Saturday, December 12, 2026.

Jay Sears is the owner and publisher of MyRye.com. He is a 20+ year Rye resident. Contact MyRye.com: https://myrye.com/tips

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *