Map showing the indication of specific areas
(PHOTO: The red boxes indicate the Rye Country Day School’s Thruway property (on the left) and 601 Midland Avenue (on the right). Credit: MyRye.com

Mayor Josh Nathan has indicated the city council will relook at the City of Rye steep slopes law that governs development on slopes greater than 25% and 35% grades. To prepare the council for its review, Corporation Council Kristen Wilson was asked to present a review of the current steep slopes law at the council meeting this past Wednesday, November 18, 2026.

Before we continue, it is the holidays and we need to ask for your support. 

MyRye.com covers the local news in Rye – city government, public safety, schools, sports, our local businesses and nonprofits & more. Please consider making an online donation to support our credible, community-based, public-service journalism. We need 77 new supporters this holiday season – we just launched our campaign and have our first three new supporters and need 74 more. [For major gifts, donor advised fund gifts, and gifts of appreciated securities, please see our other ways to give.]

Any lightening of the current law would be designed to cover and accommodate two immediate property development projects: first, Rye Country Day School, and the development of the 9 acre Thruway property and second, George Comfort & Sons’ 621 Midland Avenue. Development of both properties would currently be limited under the steep slopes law.

Rye Country Day School

Architectural drawing showing steep areas of a property
(PHOTO: Steep slope areas on Rye Country Day School’s Thruway property are shown on this drawing from Woodard & Curran. October 2026.) Credit: Rye Planning Commission

Rye Country Day School (RCDS) managed to dodge a bullet in June by negotiating its exemption from the city’s building moratorium. But the city’s planning commission was not as kind to the elite private school.

Drawings by RCDS’ civil engineering firm Woodard & Curran show three areas on the massive 9 acre Thruway property with steep slopes, two of them with slopes over 35 degrees. Under the law, construction in an area like this requires the finding of “rare and exigent” circumstances.

“Either you need to go to the city council and get them to change the law, or you need to write a memorandum that we can hang our hat on and defend it,” said Rye City Planning Commission Chair Nick Everett to school officials at the commission’s October meeting. “It puts us in an untenable position.”

It would appear RCDS is heeding Everett’s advice or perhaps Nathan is expecting the school to come knocking on the door of City Hall.

621 Midland Avenue

621 Midland, along with 601 Midland, was purchased as part of the old Avon building by George Comfort & Sons (whose CEO Peter S. Duncan is a Rye resident) back in 2019. 601 Midland is now the home of New York Blood Center. 621 Midland is a 3.25-acre parcel off Midland Avenue, sandwiched between Interstate 95, Interstate 287, and the Metro North train tracks. George Comfort & Sons has been looking to develop a self-storage facility on the site.

Since the adoption of the steep slopes law (Chapter 166A), there have been three permit applications made in 2022, two applications in 2024 and oneapplication in 2025. Of the six permits requested, four have been grantedand two are pending.

“There are projects that will come to us that are going to run headfirst into the current law, and I don’t think, again, this is just me speaking, but I don’t think the law was meant to prohibit these projects, and so I think we will be wanting to to revisit this in the coming year,” Mayor Nathan told fellow councilmembers Wednesday evening.

Jay Sears is the owner and publisher of MyRye.com. He is a 20+ year Rye resident. Contact MyRye.com: https://myrye.com/tips

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *